Talk:Kagari Shiina/@comment-202.62.18.70-20170303035521/@comment-7888499-20170303045342

Well, I'm only halfway through the VN myself, so I will leave further explanation to the others. But (highlight to read)[ That particular plot twist was in the Epigraph Trilogy light novels too. I believe the answer is, Kagari is not really Yuki. She uses Yuki's identity in some world lines but not all. This can be proven by the fact that Suzuha is born even in world lines and attractor fields where Kagari does not travel to the past. So, is the real Yuki also working for the enemy in the “Promised Rinascimento” route? Once again, I have only finished up to that chapter's end, but I think so. That route's Okabe reasoned himself into believing that Yuki could have kidnapped Kagari in other easier ways, but I think Okabe was not recognizing that Yuki is in love with Daru and wouldn't want to blow her cover and have to part from him. She probably also does not really want to continue working for an evil group, but has her own story about how she ended up with them.

Yuki being capable of the physical feats of the helmeted woman in the "Rinascimento" route is in keeping with understanding where Suzuha gets her athleticism from. ]

The conversation right below this one poses another theory, however, that the helmeted woman in the "Rinascimento" route is Judy Reyes. Personally, I don't think that Judy's height is close enough.

Moeka: 167cm B88 W59 H88

Kagari: 165cm B86 W60 H88

Yuki: 162cm B86 W60 H88

Judy: 179cm

(Sizes are from the SG0 guidebook)

And, the biggest hint is the way that Moeka, Kagari and Yuki hold their arms while wearing that ubiquitous black biker suit. It's all slightly different. Examples from the guidebook: Kagari, Yuki, Moeka